Virginia Historical Society     Click to return to the Virginia Historical Society homepage Online Exhibitions Search  
Old Virginia: The Pursuit of a Pastoral Ideal
Old Virginia: The Pursuit of a Pastoral Ideal
Old Virginia: The Pursuit of a Pastoral Ideal
Navigation
Introduction Origins of the Pastoral The Pursuit of Gentility Decline and Resistance Resurgence of the Old Order Triumph of the Colonial Past Exhibit Catalog Acknowledgements Comments
James River, 1859  

James River, Richmond, Virginia
Lefevre Cranstone
1859
Watercolor
Virginia Historical Society
Full view
space

 
Old Virginia: The Pursuit of a Pastoral Ideal

I. Origins of the Pastoral: First Century B.C.-1750

In John White's pictures, which were sketched in the 1580s at Roanoke Island, the Indians of Virginia were often depicted as living in a simpler time. They are shown to enjoy a peaceful, bountiful existence. In The Indian Village of Secoton [Full view], we see not a simple clearing in a forest primeval, but a well-established, orderly hamlet, whose citizens had carefully laid out specific areas for dwelling, eating, and worship, and who clearly had developed proper agricultural methods long before the arrival of the English. Perhaps unwittingly, commentators often pointed to the fact that the cultures that the Europeans "discovered" in the New World were themselves of long duration. Thus, from the start Englishmen were ready to associate the word "old" with Virginia.

image
Larger view

The Indian Village of Secoton
after John White
Engraving published in Theodore de Bry's America
1585–86
Virginia Historical Society


Adam and Eve
Larger view

Adam and Eve
Engraving published in Thomas Hariot, A Briefe and True Report of the Newfound Land of Virginia (London, 1590)
Virginia Historical Society, bequest of Paul Mellon

At the end of the 16th century, Virginia was viewed in England as an abundant, unspoiled, "virginal" land. It was often represented as a garden, as opposed to the howling wilderness that would await the Plymouth and Massachusetts Bay colonists. The region was even compared to Eden, the archetypal garden of the Judeo-Christian heritage. Pictured here are Adam and Eve immediately prior to the Fall, standing at the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil. The publisher of this engraving, Thomas Hariot, sought to convince Elizabeth I not to turn away from this potentially profitable "Eden" after the failure of the lost Roanoke colony.


The "Contrary Character" of Early Virginia

Virginia failed to become a treasure colony like those of Spain, nor did it develop a diversified economy that would supply the resources and goods wanted in the homeland. Instead, tobacco became the basis of its economic life. This crop permitted or even required individual settlers to establish far-flung plantations, which led to the creation of a distinctly un-English social landscape.

Some early commentators tried to explain away the perceived failures of Virginia and pointed again to the immense potential of the colony. The paradox that Virginia seemed both the best and the worst of lands was addressed in 1697 by Henry Hartwell, James Blair, and Edward Chilton in The Present State of Virginia, and the College: "As to the Natural Advantages of a Country, it is one of the best, but as to the Improved Ones, one of the worst of all the English Plantations."

It was in answer to persistently negative assessments of its development that Virginia would be reinvented in the 18th century as a pastoral society. In this way Virginians could justify their agrarian lifestyle that had been so much maligned.

The idea that the Virginia colony should be valued less for its natural resources than for its pattern of rural settlement that allowed the pursuit of virtuous living was rooted in Augustan England. There, pastoral bliss was celebrated by poets and painters, architects and landscape gardeners, and by those of the gentry who pursued an exalted lifestyle in the countryside. This ideal had originated in the ancient world and had been revived in Europe during the Renaissance.

Classical and Renaissance Models of Pastoral Life

The pastoral ideal, as it was transported to the New World, was based on models that had originated in the Europe of antiquity. This type of imagined utopia, which in its most basic form suggested the possibility for a life of simplicity and virtue in a rural, rustic setting, was extant among the ancient Greeks, with Theocritus its best-known exponent. The ideal came into full flower, however, through the writings of a number of Romans, particularly Virgil, Pliny the Younger, Horace, and Cato.

Roman ideas were revived during the Italian and English Renaissance, and later during the Neo-Classical or Augustan period in Great Britain. The number of translations, borrowings from, and allusions to the great literary works of ancient Greece and Rome during the Augustan era makes clear that many of the most important British authors of the late-17th and early 18th centuries were enamored of the ancients. This same adulation guided contemporary architects, painters, and landscape gardeners. In this environment, noblemen who were obliged to come to London to deal with economic or political affairs would retire to their country seats to study the classics and otherwise seek diversion in the life of the mind. They established a lifestyle that the elite of the Virginia colony would emulate.

The Works of Virgil
Larger view

The Works of Virgil
Joseph Trapp, ed.
London, 1731
Virginia Historical Society

Virgil was arguably the most important of the Roman authors who established the parameters of the literary pastoral. In the Eclogues he identified the satisfactions of the pastoral retreat: peace, leisure, and economic self-sufficiency. In the Georgics he inspired in future generations an interest in agriculture and animal husbandry, in the chase, and in landscape gardening. It has been said that no poem yet written has touched on these subjects with more expert knowledge or more tenderness that the Georgics. Virgil also provided an important early impetus to urban sophisticates to live at least part of their lives in the country.


Virginia
Larger view

Virginia
John Farrer
1651
Map
Virginia Historical Society

Captain John Smith's 1624 identification of Virginia as "Ould" was supported at mid-century by John Farrer, who differentiates his "Ould Virginia" from such places as the younger English colony, Maryland, and such neighboring lands as "Noua Francia." Farrer also looks back to the earliest days of the colony, but he chooses Sir Francis Drake, rather than Ralegh, as his inspiration and link to the colony's formation. This is Drake's "New Albion," which Farrer suggests may yet prove to be a middle ground between England and Asia. ("The Sea of China and the Indies" lies somewhere to Virginia's near west.) By mid-century there was no doubt about the primacy of the Virginia founding, and in 1660 Charles II would give Virginia its best-known sobriquet. The king's reference to the colony as "our auntient dominion" provided an alternative identification—"the Old Dominion"—that continues in popular usage to this day.

Introduction
I. Origins of the Pastoral
II. Pursuit of Gentility
III. Decline and Resistance
IV. Resurgence of the Old Order
V. Triumph of the Colonial Past
Exhibit Catalog
Acknowledgements
Comments

Image rights owned by the Virginia Historical Society. Do not use without permission. Rights and reproductions